Battery Giant's Bankruptcy Hits Europe's Electrification

The ambitious journey of Europe towards autonomous electric vehicle manufacturing has encountered another substantial hurdle. Northvolt, often dubbed the "European version of CATL," has recently declared bankruptcy under Chapter 11 in the United States. The company now finds itself in a precarious position, with merely $30 million in cash against a staggering debt of $5.8 billion. Once hailed as a beacon of hope for the European battery manufacturing sector, Northvolt was envisioned as a pivotal player in reducing Europe's reliance on Chinese battery producers. This ambitious plan now appears irrevocably damaged.

The heart of Northvolt's downfall lies in its inability to meet production targets. Established in Sweden in 2017 by two former Tesla executives, Northvolt garnered substantial attention and investment, with backing from prominent players like Volkswagen, Goldman Sachs, BlackRock, and Siemens, amassing more than $10 billion in funding. The company's mission was resolutely clear: to "make oil history" by developing a self-sufficient battery production capability in Europe. They aimed to produce high-quality batteries on a large scale to supply automakers like BMW and Volkswagen.

Advertisement

However, the optimism surrounding Northvolt began to wane, particularly in September of this year when the company first publicly acknowledged its operational crisis. There were vivid signs of impending collapse, underscored by production hurdles, technological limitations, and lost orders, leading to a significant trust deficit. This gradual decline may not just represent the failure of one battery manufacturer but could also signify a larger conundrum within Europe’s transition to electrification and its supply chain intricacies.

The trajectory of Northvolt's development reveals a pattern of rapid expansion and miscalculations. When it was founded, the startup saw an exponential increase in financing and orders. In fact, in 2019, before its first factory was even completed, Northvolt secured $13 billion worth of orders with forecasts predicting production capacity stretched out to 2030, resulting in founder Paolo Cerruti declaring, "We have sold out our products," despite the company not having produced a single cell at that time.

The factory in Northern Sweden was championed as a hallmark of advanced battery manufacturing. Yet, upon completion, it struggled to achieve even 1% of its capacity, falling drastically short of its intended output. Nonetheless, Northvolt announced ambitious plans to quadruple the factory's size and establish several more facilities across Europe and North America, driving the company’s resources to their limits and laying the groundwork for future financial distress.

Interviews conducted by the Financial Times with ten current and former employees highlight that Northvolt's aspirations to juggle multiple large-scale projects led to a buildup of unresolved issues. One former senior executive candidly remarked, “Manufacturing batteries is exceptionally challenging. We were trying to accomplish almost everything simultaneously, and problems kept accumulating.”

The ramifications of Northvolt's bankruptcy filing send shockwaves through Europe's aspirations for an independent battery industry. With over 70% of lithium batteries produced in China, Northvolt was seen as a bastion for establishing a robust electric vehicle supply chain independent of Asian dominance. Nevertheless, despite its endeavors to challenge the status quo, the anticipated surge in demand for battery production has failed to materialize as swiftly as some industry experts had forecasted.

The Financial Times underscored that Northvolt's misfortunes are not isolated; they symbolize the frailty of Europe's green ambitions. The ripple effects of Northvolt's bankruptcy could profoundly impact the continent's aspirations to cultivate a vibrant local battery ecosystem. As economies pivot towards greener technologies, the spotlight is now focused on the sustainability of numerous other battery projects across Europe, many of which are also shrouded in uncertainty.

Other ventures face similar fates. For instance, a joint venture between Mercedes and Stellantis, known as ACC, suspended construction of its factories in Germany and Italy. Research conducted by the Fraunhofer Institute indicated that over a quarter of the announced battery production projects in Europe are in jeopardy, suggesting that around 20 planned factories may never materialize.

In the domain of lithium battery manufacturing, Asian nations have established an overwhelming hegemony. The top ten companies in the global EV battery market hail from China, South Korea, and Japan, with CATL commanding approximately 37.5% of the market. European firms like Northvolt had ambitious plans to disrupt this entrenched hierarchy, but they have encountered unprecedented challenges.

Experts from Roland Berger, including Wolfgang Bernhardt, stress that Western battery manufacturers are lagging in technology and operational efficiencies when compared to their Asian counterparts. He advises, “European manufacturers should adopt a more pragmatic approach towards collaboration with Asian companies to bolster technological advancements and production capabilities.”

Northvolt is now pursuing a restructuring initiative under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, anticipating a completion timeline of the first quarter of next year, during which the company intends to continue its operations as it navigates through its financial turmoil. As part of this restructuring, Northvolt is on track to secure approximately $245 million in new financing. The firm aims to use this opportunity to strengthen its long-term goal of establishing a formidable battery production base within the West.

Notably, Volkswagen, owning 21% of Northvolt, has acknowledged the company's bankruptcy filing but refrains from speculating on the potential repercussions for its operations. Swedish government stakeholders, including Deputy Prime Minister Ebba Busch, have expressed support for Northvolt's rejuvenation efforts. Busch reaffirmed, via social media platform X, that the government would continue to back the electric vehicle battery sector, expressing hope that the restructuring would help alter Northvolt's dire trajectory. Nevertheless, she also clarified that the government has no intentions of acquiring shares in Northvolt.

Recent reports indicate that Goldman Sachs, Northvolt's second-largest shareholder, is preparing to write down its $896 million investment to zero by the end of the year. Sources reveal that the firm is alarmed by Northvolt's rapid expenditure of capital. Analysts from the Swedish banking sector suggest that while the bankruptcy filing grants Northvolt a short-term respite, the company has yet to identify new investors or secure the necessary funds for its restructuring efforts.

Former Tesla executive and current Chief Battery Technology Officer at Lyten, Celina Mikolajczak, underscores the complexities tied to battery manufacturing, necessitating production in sterile environments using highly specialized metals and chemicals. She elucidates that even the slightest contamination can halt production, leading to significant financial losses. The staggering costs involved in establishing battery facilities often reach billions of dollars, and the scarcity of skilled engineers possessing the requisite technical expertise magnifies the challenges.

There is a growing sentiment among shareholders that they have exhausted their patience with Northvolt's management, identifying discrepancies in alignment between their primary shareholders, Volkswagen and Goldman Sachs, as a contributing factor to Northvolt's troubles. According to Tom Johnstone, Northvolt's interim chairman, the bankruptcy process will provide a much-needed opportunity to rejuvenate funding and reorganize for continued battery production. Yet clarity prevails within the market: Northvolt is no longer the luminary it once was in Europe's quest for battery independence.